Posts

Showing posts with the label comparison

Which is Truly Better: Toronto's Subway or Montreal's Metro?

Image
 In previous blog posts, or even if we've spoken, I have stated that the Montreal Metro is better than the TTC subway, but Toronto has better transit as a whole. I've talked at length about the second part of the sentence, but I've never properly interrogated the first part. In this blog post, I will compare the two heavy rail systems on a number of criteria in order to decide which is the better system. What Am I Comparing? I will compare the systems on a number of important points. I won't be providing a number grade to each, as I think that the qualitative comparison better reflects the nuance in this comparison. The systems will be graded on: Hours of service Frequency Reliability Scheduled closures Speed Connections (walkability and destinations) Connections (other transit) Accessibility Architecture Cleanliness Safety Also, for ease of writing, Toronto's system will be referred to a the 'subway' whereas Montreal's will be referred to as the 'Me...

Toronto Needs More Bus Lanes

Image
Toronto needs and deserves more bus lanes, and there is no valid argument against them. I said it! A few days ago, I saw this tweet thread from August, who often speaks about transit issues in Toronto. I have attached the first tweet, you can see the others by clicking on it. toronto could justify bus lanes on most arterials in the city just by sheer number of buses and the ridership on these corridors (this isn't the case in most US/CA cities) and yet we only really have one proper corridor — august 🍂 (@augustAP12) May 6, 2022 August is 100% correct: the ridership on Toronto's bus routes alone justify some material improvements, end of sentence. Unfortunately, Toronto only has one bus lane corridor: the Eglinton-Kingston-Morningside RapidTO corridor, used by the 12D, 86, 116, 905 and 986 bus routes.  While many other corridors have been proposed, little progress has been made due to opposition. In this piece, I will explain why Toronto's lack of bus lanes is out of line...

No, Montreal does not have Better Transit than Toronto

Image
 One thing I always hear from Torontonians who visit Montreal is how much better transit is there. While not discrediting their beliefs, this is a bit of a biased view. In this (somewhat long) piece, I will explain why comparing cities as a tourist is a problem, as well as where Montreal's public transit networks come up lacking in comparison to Toronto. Solutions for Montreal can be extrapolated from this piece. This will focus mostly as a TTC vs. STM comparison, but some other networks will be brought up.  Why Comparing Cities as a Tourist is Biased Pitting cities against each other in a friendly competition seems like second nature. However, there are a number of critical factors to account for when comparing cities. The first factor is that present situations are a direct consequence of historic conditions and decisions. This is why advocating for 'copy-paste' solutions originating in Europe or Asia will be unsuccessful if applied as-is in North America. Ignoring coloni...